To each his own I guess. Some people like bipolar captains and some don’t. But sorry, that song is not debatable, totally sucks

10 – You’re right, she wasn’t the worst thing about Enterprise, that’s why she weighed in at # 10

8 – I agree that my interest was peeked when I first heard about a show relating to the first Enterprise ever, but that interest fades quickly unless the show keeps it going.

7 – I still believe he was miscast. He doesn’t feel like a security chief in any way.

6 – I never thought about it that way. But then, assuming you’ve seen the finale, how come Riker and Troy seem like the ones from the dimension/continuation we all know and love? Something’s not right one way or the other.

5 – Oh God no, this point I will not concede, the music is awful!

4 – Your 4 is my 3

3 – Yes, the actor who played Shran was perhaps the best actor on the show! Too bad he had blue skin and antennae All I’m saying is that I’m fed up of skin tone and ridges masking humans into Aliens. It’s not Enterprise specifically, it’s all of Star Trek/Star Wars. After BattleStar Galactica and Firefly, it’s hard to go back…

1 – Janeway wasn’t bad, but she was far from Picard and so I saw her in a negative light for a long time. Now that I’ve experience Archer, I wouldn’t mind getting Janeway back at all

10- T’Pol was not that bad. She had to cope with emotions especially at the end. Also you can’t say a Vulcan and Chinese girl mutually massaging each other with some kind of lubricant/antibiotic is not helping the increase the audience

9- Meh, good point.

8- I dunno, for a cannon fan this is rather interresting. Also it forces the writers to use imagination when you can’t fix everything with a inverse-tachyon beam.

7- The actor who did Malcom Reed perfetly played the role of a subordinate British officer. The problem is England, not the actor.

6- Enterprise is more or less set in a different universe. The Xindi attack did not happend in the Kirk universe, that’s the whole point of the temporal cold war. For example; the first contact with the Klingons should have started a war while in Enterprise it went (kinda) well. As for the Borg, the crew never see them physically or are aware of their name, therefore it could be included in the ‘cannon’ history no problem. As for the Romulans, Star Trek history says Earth (Starfleet?) and them went to war pre-kirk but no humans ever saw a Romulan before TOS, Enterprise din’t change anything to that.

5- No no no no. GREAT opening, good song and I liked the way they twisted it for the Mirror universe episodes.

4- You damn racist Just kidding, ya he sucks but every serie needs it ‘newbie’.

3- You are contradicting your arguments from article 6. Enterprise could not really introduce aliens unknonws in TOS, at least none that would be politicaly/military poweful. Futhermore the actor they took for the ‘main’ Andorian is great and the inside jokes between him and Archer (being both main actors in Quantum Leap) were great. Also it gives more credence to the relative hostility Vulcans and Andorian shows to one another in TOS.

1- Agree, I like Scott Bakula but his acting in Enterprise was terrible. But I doubt it was his fault. The writters could probably not make their mind about how the captain should be. And dont you complain about Janeway. She’s not my favorite captain by far but the actress managed to create a real character despite the writers cluelesness.